Iowa Schools: Garbage In, Garbage Out
Lloyd Miller of Des Moines writes an outstanding letter. Gosh, who would think that the society we actively create would have effects on young people being raised in that society? Kids learn exactly what we teach them.
Change culture to change schoolsIn the Feb. 13 dialog on teacher pay, both Linda Lantor Fandel and Andie Dominick are right (“Pay Teachers More?”). Iowa teachers deserve better salaries because their pay is abysmal, and, no, higher pay probably will not improve student learning.
Schools are run by adults and thus reflect their values and behavior. High school students are astute observers of adult behavior. They recognize the contradictions between what adults say and what they do.
They’re told that learning is important but see exceptions made for the best athletes and experience social promotion irrespective of academic performance. They’re told to revere their teachers but see that teacher pay is less than that of any profession requiring comparable levels of education.
They’re told that values such as honesty, integrity, care and concern for the welfare of fellow human beings and the planet are important. What they see are politicians who lie, corporate heads who cheat, and people in power who are grossly incompetent. Few are held accountable. Many students decide that personal accountability is just not that important.
To improve schools, we must understand that our cultural behavior often has consequences beyond what we intend, and if those consequences are harmful, we need to change the behavior.
— Lloyd Miller, Des Moines.
- Sousy
February 22nd, 2006 at 9:05 am
Amen to that. I’ve long felt that it’s absolutely insane the amount of head-scratching that writers and pundits go through when they prattle on about Iowa’s difficulties surrounding education. The fact remains that careers in teaching are routinely the subject of ridicule, which as far as i know, is a feature unique to the United States. It’s also rediculous when “free market” conservatives do a 180 when it comes to teacher pay. It seems their simplistic metaphors don’t apply when it comes to providing a fatter carrot on that particular stick.